Gandalf vs. Dumbledore vs. Merlin

[(=DK=)Samonuh]

Battle to the death. Who would win? Go:

[CommanderOtto]

Battle to the death. Who would win? Go:

Merlin FTW

[SWINE FLU]

It has to be Merlin, no questions asked. But between Gandalf and Dumbledore, I'd say Gandalf.

[Darth Crater]

It depends. Gandalf is one of the Maiar, but he holds back a lot. Moreso as the Grey than as the White. His biggest battle was the fight with the Balrog, which was offscreen. Dumbledore tends to display more direct combat power, but he's still human. Then again, if he has the Elder Wand, he'll be pretty hard to beat. I'd say Gandalf wins if he doesn't have to hold back, Dumbledore wins (temporarily) otherwise.

Merlin, of course, wins by having time travel. Dumbledore would have it too, but people in the Harry Potter universe are incapable of abusing it for some reason.

[/overanalysis]

[Dad]

Raistlin, hands down.

[GDog]

Haha I would have to agree with Dad... No one could catch him with those rabbits

[(SWGO)Minas_Thirith]

Gandalf hold back quite a bit considering his race.
If Gandalf indeed were not to hold back in anything he'd be invincible, remember, as "Gandalf the grey" he was able to beat the Balrog.

MT

[(=DK=)Samonuh]

Gandalf hold back quite a bit considering his race.
If Gandalf indeed were not to hold back in anything he'd be invincible, remember, as "Gandalf the grey" he was able to beat the Balrog.

MT

He didn't defeat the Balrog. It was a tie.

[(SWGO)Minas_Thirith]

Gandalf hold back quite a bit considering his race.
If Gandalf indeed were not to hold back in anything he'd be invincible, remember, as "Gandalf the grey" he was able to beat the Balrog.

MT

He didn't defeat the Balrog. It was a tie.

And yet, Gandalf came back, the balrog didn't.
As far as i recall it "Gandalf finally trew down his oponent, after he fell into darkness, and was sent back"

MT

[Hobo]

Dumbledore. He had the elder wand, and the elder wand can't lose in a duel.